I Am Frankelda (2025)

So this is apparently a prequel to a successful Mexican stop-motion animation show. I’ve never heard of it and only came across it by chance on Netflix which I’d consider a marketing failure because it looks amazing. Its team has achieved results that I didn’t was possible with dolls, cloth and other physical props. The story starts promisingly, reminding of me The Neverending Story but unfortunately rushes to an incoherent ending. I suppose it is a prequel after all and fans already know how it’s meant to connect with the preexisting series. I’m not entirely satisfied with the story but it truly is one of the more original animated films I’ve watched and so it gets my recommendation.

As a little girl, Francesca Imelda delights in dreaming up tales of the macabre with her mother’s encouragement. After her mother passes, she is raised by her grandmother who disdains her writing and puts her to work mending socks. Unbeknownst to her, the characters that she writes about are real in the nightmare realm of Topus Terrenus. The denizens of the realm are suffering as the nightmares created by Procustes, the Royal Nightmare Maker, no longer hold the power to terrify dreaming humans. As a child, the prince of the realm Herneval discovers that he is able to travel to the real world and secretly pays Francesca a visit. Ten years later, the adult Francesca tries to get her stories published but is rejected. Meanwhile Topus Terrenus continues to weaken. Procustes incites its denizens to rebel against the King and Queen and invade the real world like in the old days. Herneval appears before Francesca and persuades her to follow him to his realm in spirit form to show her stories to the royal court.

The film’s outstanding visuals speak for themselves. The amount of detail of the puppets and the complexity of their movements blow every other stop-motion animation I’ve seen out of the water. The first scene has Francesca as a child with her mother, standing on grass that ripples in the wind. There are clouds that grow grasping hands, large set-piece battles, monstrously-sized creatures and impressive special effects. You genuinely wonder how they achieved all that with puppets and so the making-of video during the credits is instructive. I know that all stop-motion animation involves an immense amount of work but moving and changing the minute parts of so many objects for every scene as seen here is truly excessive. This is a musical as well and the songs are decently good even if I don’t understand the Spanish lyrics. It’s a wonderful and highly original spectacle that I’d judge to be superior in quality to North American productions by major studios. I’m surprised it isn’t better known and I think it could easily appeal to a wider audience if it were better marketed.

The name Frankelda gave me the impression that this would be some female variant of the Frankenstein story which is not at all the case. Here as Francesca seemingly writes Herneval and his entire world into being, it’s more reminiscent of The Neverending Story especially with her being called on to revitalize the realm through inciting fear. The ontology isn’t quite consistent however as Herneval is perfectly capable of acting independently of her and Topus Terrenus has a longer, more complex history than anything Francesca wrote. I’m also irked that at the end the realm is seemingly fine without Francesca’s help and Procustes’ rebellion is defeated by the deux ex machina of a couple of barons showing up to help. Some plotlines, such as the young man who is interested in Francesca in the real world, go nowhere. Francesca’s character feels off to me when she blows up at Herneval for little reason, almost as if the spirit version of her is really some malevolent ghost. At one point, the story feels more about Francesca getting proper credit for her writing than saving Topus Terrenus.

So I Am Frankelda is jaw-dropping as a spectacle but a bit of a letdown in terms of story and characterization. To me, it’s such an unforgiveable omission that the film talks up how amazing Francesca’s writing is, yet never shows us one of her stories onscreen. For that matter, why humanity is seemingly no longer scared of nightmares is not addressed. I can only surmise that Frankelda’s stories are already the subject of the episodic show so there was no need to expound on them in this prequel. I do still recommend it because it looks so good and is so unique but maybe keep in mind that it’s primarily aimed at fans of the show.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

6 + twenty =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.